Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Dexcom Decision

I feel guilty for not getting this post up sooner. I've been busy, crazy, stressed, and uninspired. However over due it is, here's my post about the decision I made regarding the Dexcom trial.
Over the week that I trialed Dex, I was fairly happy with the results. They were pretty much dead on with what was going on (including matching, almost always, my MiniMed CGMS). There were some areas that I felt that Dex did have some amazing things going for it.

First off, it catches a turn around in blood sugars more quickly than the MiniMed counterpart. Secondly, they are FDA approved for 7 days. Much more than the 3 days that the MiniMed is. Also, the Dex does not have to be taped down 10 thousand ways to keep it on (I use two pieces of medical tape and two IV-3000 tape pieces to hold down my MiniMed).

Another thing I loved about the Dexcom was that I could put the receiver on my night stand next to my head and it I ALWAYS heard it alarm (it vibrates before beeping, and let me tell you, on a wooden nightstand it will wake me up). As I've talked about previously, I don't always here my MiniMed alarms at night.

But, then there were the down sides to the Dexcom. I didn't like that you couldn't see past results on the graph. You can only see what your most recent result is; the rest is only a graph. On MiniMed, you can scroll back through the numbers. Even though graphs are incrediably visual and helpful, sometimes I like to see an actual number.

Then there was the fact that it was a separate device to lug around. I had such a horrible time remembering to bring it with me. And if you happen to get so far away that you're out of range, you've lost the numbers/readings from that time period. With MiniMed, the transmitter stores up to 30 minutes of results and feeds it to the pump once you are back in range. Often times at work I am up from my desk and walking around my office. Sometimes I get stuck somewhere else for a while (20 minutes or so at times) in another area helping a client. If my Dex receiver is laying on my desk, it's lost all of those readings. One morning I even left the receiver at home and had to come back to get it after I got to work.

Honestly, separate device and all, if the readings were more accurate than MiniMed for me, I probably would have been more willing to switch to Dexcom, especially with the ability to hear the alarms at night. But, I decided to stick with MiniMed because there honestly wasn't a huge difference in readings for me (I've always had decent results with MiniMed) and I loathed having another device to lug around in addition to my meter, pump, phone, and mp3 player.

Here's my honest advice to anyone thinking about trying out either the MiniMed or the Dexcom: TRY THEM BOTH. And give them both a chance. If Dexcom already had their integration with the Animas pump, I might have actually made the switch. But for now, I like having only one device to deal with.

As with anything, Your Diabetes May Vary. I know a lot of people have horrible results with MiniMed's CGMS and do much, much better on Dexcom. I'm glad that you found one that works so well for you. But since they were both so similar in accuracy, it really came down to convenience for me. And MiniMed won out.

I would like to say that everyone I dealt with at Dexcom was amazing. From the first person I spoke with on the phone to the wonderful Dexcom rep that met me to get me started with the trial. These people truly seem to love their job and believe in their product. And I'd like to thank them for the opportunity to compare the two systems. It meant a lot to work that out for myself and see what was the best fit for me.

7 comments:

shannon said...

thanks so much for this wrap-up post. i've been following along with great interest, since my daughter is interested in switching from minimed to dexcom. it seems the best way is to compare for yourself, so i may look into a dexcom trial. thanks again!

Karen G said...

I've been wondering what you ended up deciding. I know it sounds weird, but I'm kind of glad you are sticking with MM. Well, I should say I'm glad to hear MM gives you results that are just as accurate as Dex. I really do love my MM - and the reasons you mentioned for not switching are the same reasons I'll stay with MM too.

The DL said...

Thank you for your honest report!! Love the advice :)

Sara said...

Other than being convinced that everyone should at least give the MultiClix a try (because they will realize it is the best lancet out there) I say - to each their own.

I love my DexCom because it works for me. If the MM works for you, then why switch?

George said...

To each his own! I totally agree. Try both and see what works for you.

Tricia said...

I wish I saw this earlier!! How do you get a Dexcom trial? I was told it couldn't be done, but there is a 30 day money back guarantee.

NeurosurgeryNP said...

I am "trialing" the Dex now. Have 30 days to give it back should I not like it more than my MM. Have been using MM with good success, but CDE convinced me to give it a try. The one issue (actually two) I have had with the MM is the taping (using Tegaderm) is starting to rip off my skin on removal, and the needle size and always bleeding after insertion. After the first Dex insertion, I can say that Dex is hands down better for me. I know I will have problems remembering the receiver, but will stick it out for a couple of weeks to see how it works for me.